Freestanding vs. Built-In Bathtubs: Which is Better?

October 31, 2024

So, you’re ready to take the plunge (pun intended) into a new bathtub, but are you leaning toward a freestanding or a built-in style? It’s no secret that a bathtub can be a game-changer in your bathroom’s design, vibe, and, of course, comfort level. Both freestanding and built-in bathtubs have distinct features, and each comes with its own set of advantages and trade-offs.

In this article, we’re going to break down the freestanding vs. built-in bathtubs: pros and cons so you can choose the one that suits your style, budget, and space needs. From ease of installation to visual impact, we’ve got it all covered. Ready to dive in?

What’s the Big Difference? Freestanding vs. Built-In Bathtubs

Before diving into pros and cons, let’s first define each style.

Freestanding Bathtubs: As the name suggests, these tubs stand alone without being attached to a wall. Freestanding tubs are often elegant, eye-catching, and bring a touch of luxury to your bathroom.
Built-In Bathtubs: These tubs are integrated into the bathroom layout, usually installed against a wall or in an alcove. Built-in tubs are space-efficient, practical, and generally easier to clean around.

Pros of Freestanding Bathtubs

Freestanding bathtubs bring a unique aesthetic appeal to any bathroom, often becoming the room's centerpiece. But aesthetics aren’t the only perk!

1. Visual Appeal

Freestanding tubs are a sight to behold! They add a touch of luxury and can make any bathroom feel like a spa.
They come in a variety of styles: from modern minimalistic designs to vintage clawfoot tubs.

2. Flexible Placement

Freestanding tubs can be placed anywhere, as long as the plumbing permits. Want it by a window for a scenic soak? Or smack in the middle of the bathroom as a bold design statement? Go for it!

3. Larger Selection of Shapes and Sizes

Since they aren’t confined by walls, you’ll find freestanding tubs in countless shapes and sizes, from egg-shaped to rectangular to slipper-shaped.

4. Ideal for Statement-Making Designs

Freestanding tubs make a bold statement in the bathroom, bringing an elevated sense of design. It’s no wonder they’re often found in high-end resorts and spa-like homes!

Cons of Freestanding Bathtubs

Freestanding tubs aren’t perfect. Here are some potential drawbacks to keep in mind:

1. Space Requirements

Freestanding tubs usually need more space than built-in tubs, both for aesthetic balance and practical use.
If your bathroom’s on the smaller side, a freestanding tub may make the space feel cramped.

2. More Costly Installation

The installation process can be more complicated, especially if your plumbing doesn’t already accommodate a freestanding tub.
On top of the tub’s cost, you might have to budget for plumbing adjustments or reinforcements if your floor can’t support the weight of the tub.

3. Cleaning Challenges

Because they’re freestanding, there’s space around the tub that needs regular cleaning, which can be tricky in tight bathroom spaces.

4. Limited Storage Options

Freestanding tubs don’t have the convenient ledges that built-in tubs offer for storing shampoos, soaps, or other bathing essentials.

Pros of Built-In Bathtubs

For many homeowners, built-in tubs tick all the right boxes in terms of functionality and practicality. Let’s explore their benefits.

1. Space Efficiency

Built-in tubs are great for smaller bathrooms as they fit snugly against walls, leaving more floor space open.
Alcove-style tubs are especially compact and can double as a shower area, maximizing space.

2. Easier to Clean and Maintain

Built-in tubs sit flush with walls and usually have tiling or caulking, which makes cleaning a breeze since there aren’t hard-to-reach areas around the tub.

3. Better Storage Options

Since built-in tubs are often enclosed on multiple sides, you’ll have more room for storage options, like a ledge for toiletries or even built-in shelves.

4. Lower Installation Costs

Installation is generally simpler and cheaper for built-in tubs, especially if the bathroom is already plumbed for one.
You’ll also save on additional plumbing modifications, as built-in tubs typically have straightforward drain configurations.

Cons of Built-In Bathtubs

While built-in tubs have clear advantages, they’re not without their drawbacks. Here’s what to watch out for:

1. Limited Design Flexibility

Built-in tubs are somewhat constrained in terms of placement, often tucked into a corner or an alcove. They don’t allow for much design creativity.
If you crave a stand-out piece in your bathroom, a built-in tub may not have the same impact as a freestanding model.

2. Smaller Range of Styles and Shapes

Built-in tubs generally come in rectangular shapes to fit within an alcove or against a wall, which limits your design options compared to the many shapes available for freestanding tubs.

3. Less Impact as a Focal Point

Since built-in tubs are installed flush against walls, they don’t stand out as much. For those who want a luxurious, spa-like focal point, built-in tubs don’t quite pack the same punch as freestanding ones.

4. Harder to Change in the Future

Built-in tubs are a bit more permanent. If you want to remodel down the road or upgrade your bathtub, changing a built-in tub can be more involved, especially if it’s part of a tiled alcove.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing

1. Bathroom Size

Freestanding tubs need space to shine, while built-in tubs maximize space in smaller bathrooms.

2. Budget

Freestanding tubs may cost more overall due to higher purchase and installation costs.
Built-in tubs are generally more affordable and simpler to install.

3. Maintenance and Cleaning

Built-in tubs win here for easy cleaning, as they’re flush against walls, minimizing hard-to-reach spots.

4. Design Aesthetic

Go for freestanding if you want that “wow” factor, and consider built-in for a minimalist, functional look.

Related Article: Types of Bathtub Materials

FAQs

1. Are freestanding tubs worth the extra cost?

Absolutely, if you’re after a luxurious, high-end look! Freestanding tubs make a bathroom feel elegant and can even boost home value. However, they do require a bit more investment in space and installation.

2. Which type of tub is best for small bathrooms?

Built-in tubs are your best bet for small spaces. They fit snugly against walls, maximize floor space, and double as a shower in a pinch.

3. Can you shower in a freestanding tub?

Yes, but it’s a bit tricky. Freestanding tubs don’t typically come with a shower enclosure, so you might need to install a shower curtain rail or a custom glass screen.

4. How long do freestanding and built-in tubs last?

Both styles can last decades with proper care. Built-in tubs might be slightly easier to maintain due to their enclosed nature, but freestanding tubs are also durable if kept in good condition.

Conclusion

When it comes to freestanding vs. built-in bathtubs: pros and cons, it ultimately boils down to your space, style, and budget. Freestanding tubs are fabulous for adding a bold statement, ideal for larger bathrooms and those who want a luxury feel. Built-in tubs, on the other hand, are practical, space-efficient, and more affordable to install, making them the go-to choice for compact spaces or traditional designs.

Back to blog